Tuesday, 4 November 2008

Valuecap: More Questions From Assurances

I am perplexed. I tried re-reading the articles again and again trying to figure out what makes the Valuecap shareholders so happy that they are willing to settle for mere 3.5% coupon rate and RM135 million dividend for an investment they made back in 2003 which technically was restructured in 2006.

The fact that there are 3 shareholders namely, Khazanah, KWAP and PNB investing in Valuecap and lending them monies with such low returns makes me wonder what was the other factors that Khazanah, KWAP and PNB would have considered lending Valuecap RM5 billion facility with 3-year tenor.

Source: http://goal-exchange.com/?p=104

I mean PNB paid its investors annual dividends of more than 7% per annum while KWAP is tasked with managing the pension funds of the civil servants. Surely settling for something akin to inflation rate is not going to help much with the growing burden of supporting the pensioners or getting close to the more than 7% annual dividend PNB unitholders look forward to right? As for Khazanah, well, they still have to answer for a lot of weird investments like Silterra so for this purpose, I will just leave it out for now.

I wonder, in providing financing, would they have asked themselves as they quietly ponder their investment papers on how Valuecap is going to pay back the principal back? Afterall, with Valuecap main activities revolve around buying undervalued stocks which technically need a medium to long term timeframe to exit, is it unreasonable for them to ask for a timeline of sort for orderly disposal and building up of cash reserve to repay (since it is safe to assume now that these debts consist of bullet repayment).

Again, they may have nagging feeling that considering the size Valuecap was investing in, if Valuecap was forced to sell at the last moment i.e. around Feb 2006, that would negate the reason Valuecap was set up at that time which was to provide support and build confidence in our local share markets and undervalued counters. So did they?

For further assurance, not that they don't trust their fellow GLC or state agencies, being independent and with interests of stakeholders such as pensioners and unitholders at hand, shouldn't they too requested for undertakings from Valuecap to ensure that they stick to some sort of sell down schedule?

For PNB and KWAP, which are no strangers to managing funds and investing in the share market, wouldn't they too might have considered that in the event Valuecap can't sell down, they could settle for in-kind like taking the shares at that point in time (with perhaps a slight discount) as payments rather than settling for cash if Valuecap fails to follow the dsupposed isposal schedule? But did they asked and considered such possibilities?

Or perhaps in lending, did the Government also guaranteed the RM5 billion advanced in 2003 and that perhaps has been the major scoring point the lenders take into consideration in lending those monies in the first place? If such is the case, why didn't they call on that guarantee in 2006?

Source: http://www.bowmancoaching.co.uk/coaching.html

And now we are back to the same question, why then are they happy to settle for mere 3.5% coupon rate and RM135 million dividend return made over close to 6 years investment?

Meanwhile, left with more questions rather than assurances from the Minister himself, I am not too glad he only allowed for employees to voluntarily reduce EPF contribution by 3% for the next 2 years. I wish he should have been more specific, like for those with housing loan, they can opt to not contribute for 2 years and use their monies to pay off their housing loans.

Surely that would have encouraged more people to consider settling their loans faster. That may free up more monies and encourage the banks to lend more as their loans to deposit ratio will reduce further.

Unlike the Government, I will admit why I favour that as I do have an ulterior motive. I just want to contribute as little as possible into a forced savings plan I don't trust and sure as hell want to pay for something I am quite happy to live with.

So can we have less beating about the bush and just more frankness in the explanations given?

Monday, 3 November 2008

And it comes in 5s

Today is Monday. I dread Mondays. Monday is the day signifying the start of the working week. And on these days, I have to wake up 5 minutes past 6. I have to leave my house 15 minutes before 7 in hope that I will reach my wife's office about 45 minutes later.

Source: http://drewmaniac.blogspot.com/2007/10/chucks-and-mondays.html


I know I have to work late on Mondays because it usually takes longer to get the working mood in order. I left around 9.35 pm today and I paid my RM5 parking as well.

On Sundays, I usually lament around 5 pm as the sun slowly sets at the western horizon and I dread the next day which reminds me the 5 working torturous days ahead. Oh how I dread Mondays.

And today, guess what?

I was surprised that Valuecap owes its shareholders RM5 billion which it does not seem to be able to pay. And EPF is supposed to loan them RM5 billion on the basis that they are a good investment company which will profit from taking advantage of undervalued stocks (but for the fact that Valuecap's superior-investment-research-technique-investing-on-portfolio-basis includes getting the lenders to lengthen their repayment by another 3 years which was conveniently forgotten to be mentioned by both current finance ministers and the immediate past one as well).

Will EPF face the same come whenever it is supposed to collect back its principal loaned? Well we know Valuecap has set a precedent which it may or may not follow. It really depends on its superior-investment-research-technique-investing-on-portfolio-basis.

And before the day concluded, I read about Tony Pua was upset with the RM5 billion or so losses Silterra suffered. And guess what Silterra and Valuecap has in common? Khazanah Nasional as their main shareholder and creating an impression that monies grow on trees.

Source: http://library.thinkquest.org/J003358F/trivia.html

Sigh... if only I bury my head under the pillow and let the Mondays and 5s pass right by...

Sunday, 2 November 2008

No floor please...

I guess the title said it all.

I am against setting a floor price for petrol even if the average world crude oil prices fall below US$65 per barrel. Instead, I am for removal of the subsidy by stalling the announcement of revision of the petrol prices until such time when the fallen average prices fully eliminates the current 30 sen blanket subsidy petrol pump given.

Source: http://adsoftheworld.com/media/ambient/jobsintown_de_petrol_pump?size=_original

In other words, if average crude oil prices hovers between US$65 to US$70 per barrel and the 30 sen blanket subsidy reduces to say 10 sen, then we should keep the present RM2.15 even if it justifies the Government reducing to RM1.95 to maintain the 30 sen blanket subsidy.

However, if the average prices falls below US$65 per barrel and the real petrol pump prices without subsidy is at RM1.90 (if not lower), why should we keep it at a RM1.92 floor price? I don't see why it should turn into indirect taxes of 2 sen imposed on the rakyat by setting a floor price when global crude prices fall further below US$65 per barrel.

His argument that the public would not be wise in spending if the Government allows this essential item to be treated as a cheap product is a double talk as far as I see it. If the Government can tell the rakyat to buckle up when the petrol pump prices are revised upwards thereby implicitly credit the rakyat's ability to be prudent, why shouldn't the same implicit concept be assumed when the prices are falling? There are 2 reasons that Sharir should be aware of as Domestic Tade and Consumer Affairs Minister namely:

Firstly, the volatility in petrol prices would ensure the rakyat be aware that they now directly contribute to increasing petrol prices and the Government is not going to give them blanket subsidies like in the past hence some prudence on their part is needed.

Secondly, this is the golden opportunity for the Government to use the savings to implement proper public transportation system as well as channel it to developing other regions to take away the over-development activities in places like Klang Valley. This will slow further inter-state migrations and in the longer term, place less stress on existing public infrastructure, deferring things like building a 3rd lane to existing 2-lane carriageways because more people decided to live in suburbs near KL and PJ.

Source: http://mindacergas.wordpress.com/2007/06/11/smart-tunnel-and-kl-floods/

If the Government is genuinely concerned with the rakyat treating petrol as dirt cheap essential item, then impose a tranparent consumption taxes (like the 5% sales tax). I am sure it is easier for the rakyat to know how the Government price their probably "imprudent" spending behaviour. Or alternatively, give us the rakyat the formula and timely data (audited and checked by our Auditor General) to gauge for themselves how the pump petrol prices are derived. Unlike , I am are quite happy with itemised biling.

As for the RM2.70 petrol price ceiling, our outgoing PM only promised to keep it until 31 December 2008. Within the next 59 days, barring any sudden spike in average crude oil prices, I doubt this ceiling resolve will be tested and from 1 January 2009, the Government are not obliged to keep any ceiling prices.

The Government should see this as an opportunity as Shahrir said, to use the monies allocated for subsidies to instead direct to much needed development spending to build up our economy.

But no floor price please (or ceiling for that matter)...